Interaction Design Lab · MOBILE HEALTH SYSTEM

How might we help users gather & interpret their own health data?

Increasing costs and inadequate healthcare resources have created a worldwide need for more affordable diagnostic tools that are also portable, fast, and easy to use. However, research regarding patient interpretation of traditional medical tests highlights the risks in making complex health data available to a general audience. I led an iterative, user-centered design process to create a low-cost mobile health app and device.

BY THE NUMBERS

  • 3result formats compared: number, natural language, chart
  • 13person interdisciplinary team
  • 3biomarkers tested
Experiment
Fig. 1 — We used a user-centered, iterative design process to create a new mobile health system.
DATE
Spring 2016 - Summer 2018
ORGANIZATION
Interaction Design Lab
ROLE
ResearchDesignStrategy
DELIVERABLES
TEAM
5 Mechanical Engineers5 Information Scientists3 Nutritionists
PUBLICATIONS
Journal of Medical Internet Research (JMIR)JMIRNature Scientific ReportsThesis

Design Process

  1. 01

    Problem Definition & Empathy

    A prototype already existed when I joined the project, but no formal design methods had been considered. I began the design process by empathizing with users through in-lab sessions as well as formally defining the problem with our multidisciplinary stakeholders. This resulted in the first understanding of user needs and receptivity to such a system.

  2. 02

    Online Survey

    Our sessions with potential users uncovered major discomfort and confusion around interpreting health data, so we used an online survey to determine how to design our results interface so that the data could be confidently understood by users.

  3. 03

    Design Refinement & Usability Study

    Following additional ideation, a new prototype was designed taking into account the original prototype's usability issues and design recommendations from the user survey. The new design, including hardware and a corresponding app, was a complete redesign of the original system, so we again performed usability testing.

  4. 04

    Final Design & Usability Study

    Using the new set of usability refinements and accessibility recommendations, we refined the prototype once more and performed a final round of usability testing. The resulting final design is portable, easy to use, and beneficial for a wide group of potential users, including in point-of-care contexts.

Before joining the project, no formal design processes had been used in creating the original prototype, so the initial design critique uncovered a number of issues involving:

  • Overall usability

  • Software compatibility

  • Physical specifications

  • Contamination concerns

Image showing the initial prototype attached to an iPad, as well as an enlargement showing the internal parts
The first prototype consisted of a plastic accessory that clips around an Apple iPhone or iPad, a disposable lateral flow assay test strip, and an app that processes images and displays results.

In investigating how users interpret health data, we presented hypothetical results from several blood tests via one of several designs:

  • Number representing the raw measurement of the tested biomarker

  • Natural language text indicating whether the biomarker’s level was low or high

  • Chart illustrating this level along a low-healthy axis

Nine results screens were shown to users, including 3 different biomarkers (ie, vitamin B12, procalcitonin, and cholesterol) and 3 different designs: number, natural language, and chart
We measured users’ correctness in evaluating these results and their confidence in their interpretations. They also told us about any follow-up actions they would take based on the result and how they envisioned, generally, using this system.
Image showing CAD of 4 design ideas and a rendering of the chosen design
On the basis of criteria identified during the Definition and Empathy steps, the team Ideation process resulted in various design ideas (left). After considering practicality (like the need to house specific internal components) and user needs, we decided to prototype and test a cylindrical design (right).
A rendering of the final design and app and a photo of the final design high fidelity prototype
Our final design eliminates usability and accessibility issues with the previous prototype (eliminating of the confusing pull-out tray, asymmetry to inherently illustrate the correct device orientation). A rendering of the device and app are shown on the left, and a photo of the high fidelity prototype is shown on the right.

Design Recommendations for Mobile Health

Through our iterative design process, we uncovered design considerations that extend to the development of other mobile health technologies.

  • Adhere to the principles of universal design and accessibility.

    • Make designs platform-agnostic to promote accessibility and capitalize on users' familiarity with their own devices
    • Large, dark fonts on a white background was viewed as a vital element for accessibility among our diverse user population
    • Large navigation buttons and straightforward, simple language aided users in progressing through the app instructions
    • Visual aids (such as diagrams, photos, video) are helpful in guiding users through the procedure
  • Enjoyable operation and design may aid adoption and adherence.

  • Employ hybrid feedback designs when showing health data.

    • Designs should include multiple representational modalities (numbers, words, and visuals) to tap into different literacies and increase a display's effectiveness
    • If it is not possible to include multiple types of feedback in the interface (like too little space), use text-based feedback, where natural language is used to convey whether a result is “healthy,” “high,” or “low”
    • Include a “healthy reference range” alongside results, especially for less familiar health indicators (such as procalcitonin)
    • For tests with vital consequences, use mobile health systems as a mediator between clinician and patient
  • To encourage long-term adoption, the experience needs to bring joy

    • Throughout the design process, consistently verify that users are enjoying the experience and will continue to come back